The Great Boer War Illustrated Edition Sir Arthur Conan Doyle 9781406882391 Books
Download As PDF : The Great Boer War Illustrated Edition Sir Arthur Conan Doyle 9781406882391 Books
Conan Doyle's account of the Boer War was completed in September 1900 at a time when the British believed the war was over, and first published that year by Smith, Elder & Co. The author constantly revised it and by the end of the war in 1902 the book had been published in 16 editions. It is reprinted from the final edition, complete with maps and an appendix showing the numbers of those killed and wounded.
The Great Boer War Illustrated Edition Sir Arthur Conan Doyle 9781406882391 Books
A very prejudiced tome on the Boer War from the British perspective. I know many South Africans, mainly Afrikaners. They are some of the toughest people on earth. The Brits stole their land from them, burned their farms and incarcerated their women and children in concentration camps, where 20,000 died from starvation and disease. A friend of mine's grandmother survived the camps and died a few years ago at 101 years old. She carried a lifelong hatred for the British and the treatment she received at their hands. A better book covering both sides is The Boer War by Thomas Pakenham.Product details
|
Tags : The Great Boer War (Illustrated Edition) [Sir Arthur Conan Doyle] on Amazon.com. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. Conan Doyle's account of the Boer War was completed in September 1900 at a time when the British believed the war was over,Sir Arthur Conan Doyle,The Great Boer War (Illustrated Edition),Echo Library,1406882399,HISTORY Military Wars & Conflicts (Other),HistoryAfrica - South - General,HistoryMilitary - Strategy
People also read other books :
- Crossing Winston Churchill 9781287536529 Books
- Love Courtship and Marriage A Baha'i Perspective edition by Joan Barstow Hernandez Religion Spirituality eBooks
- The Key Eternal Battle Andrea M Mouser 9781500946883 Books
- Shadow Keeper M K Yarbrough 9781461142072 Books
- MILCReeK PoND eBook Kay Carroll
The Great Boer War Illustrated Edition Sir Arthur Conan Doyle 9781406882391 Books Reviews
Whenever you write a book about the Boer War it will be compared to the great works of Packenham and Farwell. This is an incredibly detailed and scholarly study. Sadly it is a little "dry" and does not have the impact of the other two author's works.
That is of no importance to me and others who seek depth of history of this time. However if you are looking for a great fast-moving epic like "Goodbye Dolly Grey" then you will find this a little too fiber-filled!
Sir Arthur is however unique in that he really tries to illustrate the complexity, power, God-fearing, independent, tough, and woefully stubborn character of the Boer. He does this with wonderful fairness and class. It was easier to understand why this motley bunch of farmers with great weapons, rapid mobility, decent leadership and dedication could make such fools of 5 or 6 of the then top 10 British generals ... especially the darling of the Victorian age Sir Redvers "Reverse" Buller VC. Who at times seemed to be losing the war against himself ... never mind the Boers!
"Remember Majuba Tommy!"
Sir Arthur served in this conflict and this tomb appears to give the "rebellious" Boars a fair accounting. Though I suspect they would likely take issue with at least the causes and actions that led to the conflict. The British decision to create "concentration" camps (CC) for Boar wifes and children, as an inducement to break the will of the fighters, was deplorable. It arguably worked to some degree but the poorly administered camps led to astonishly high mortality overshadowed only by the Nazi CC of WWII. Sir Arthur is an excellent story teller and this book attests to his skill as a credible historian as well.
"The Great Boer War" was written by Arthur Conan Doyle, the author of the Sherlock Holmes series. The version was published in September, 1902 - some four months after the final surrender. Sixteen previous editions were published, revised as the war dragged on and more information became available.
Doyle himself served as a doctor for two months in a South African hospital, and he visited many of the locations he describes. His style is a bit stiff, but he includes great descriptions of the terrain over which the war was waged. He includes a great deal of local color and anecdotes. My favorite is of General Robert Baden-Powell (also the founder of the Boy Scouts), who, as commander of the besieged city of Mafeking and after six weeks of bombardment, notified the Boer commander that if he continued the shelling he (Baden-Powell) would consider it an act of war!
The style is that to be expected form a Victorian-era imperialist such as Doyle. Units that suffered the most casualties are always referred to having gained the most glory. The British soldiers were brave and honorable; the Boers they opposed were brave but ignorant, lucky, and dishonorable. Boer casualties are always assumed to be greater than the British, as are the Boers generally considered to outnumber the British. He ignores the true reason the British government was willing to engage in such a destructive war over otherwise valueless hinterland diamonds and gold.
An example of the bias is in describing the status of prisoners. The British considered the Boers to be rebels and traitors; thus prisoners that were paroled by the Boers on an oath not to bear arms upon release were in fact rearmed and sent back to the battle line. The British felt that an oath to such scum need not be honored. The Boers quickly determined that (since they could not accommodate prisoners) they would not require the oath - which would not abided by anyway. A compensating advantage was the British soldiers quickly realized that if they fought on they would be killed, but that if they surrendered they would be well-treated and released within a few days.
On the other hand, Boers who were paroled would be executed if caught again - for not honoring their paroles. The British stopped issuing paroles and instead sent prisoners to concentration camps in St. Helena, Ceylon, and Bermuda - where (since they were not recognized as true soldiers) they were not given the rights of prisoners of war.
Another bias is Doyle's glossing over of the methods by which the British prevailed. The country was crisscrossed with blockhouses and barbed wire. The land was burnt, crops and cattle were requisitioned or destroyed, and women, children and old men were taken to concentration camps. The death rate among Boer inmates was horrendous, with half the children perishing. There were 45 such camps for Boer non-combatants, and 64 for Black Africans - which had an even greater death rate.
That said, this is a worthwhile book for anyone interested in this fascinating period. It certainly provides the British perspective. But it also goes into great (sometimes almost boring) detail of the campaigns - all from the British perspective, of course. It includes a great many engagements, sometimes very small, that are usually ignored but cumulatively add a lot to the reader's knowledge.
My only reservation is this The reader should read some more balanced accounts (such as Pakenham's account of the war) before tackling this one. Taken by itself, Doyle's account would be very misleading. And, as usual, there are no maps. I found a couple fairly good maps by Googling, but the best were Pakenham's.
The Boer War (1895- 1902)
The author, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, gives the reason behind the cause of the war. There is rather an extensive, and interesting history that lead to the situation that the country found itself in. The military tactics required a special approach for the South African Campaign. I found that I could not stop reading because I wanted to know how a certain campaign turned out and what happened next. I am glad I read the book because it gave me an understanding into what the Boer war was about.
It almost as if two wars were fought ,one conventional ,and one guerilla. The war was conducted in a gentlemanly fashion by both sides as far as war would allow, especially by their treatment of prisoners, but it is not to say that they did not take advantage of the situation wherever they could. It was a victory for South Africa on the side of justice that was not so easily won.
Of special interest is a short story for the reader which goes as follows; to the North of Estcourt (a town) General Hildyard was receiving reinforcements via ships in its campaign against Colenso (a town) to relieve the siege of Ladysmith ( another town) on Nov. 15th. An armored train was sent form Estcourt to survey the situation. Winston Churchill was among its passengers and the train was ambushed by the Boers. Churchill became the trains driver and escaped in the cab along with the wounded. Winston Churchill was a well known correspondent at the time.
A very prejudiced tome on the Boer War from the British perspective. I know many South Africans, mainly Afrikaners. They are some of the toughest people on earth. The Brits stole their land from them, burned their farms and incarcerated their women and children in concentration camps, where 20,000 died from starvation and disease. A friend of mine's grandmother survived the camps and died a few years ago at 101 years old. She carried a lifelong hatred for the British and the treatment she received at their hands. A better book covering both sides is The Boer War by Thomas Pakenham.
0 Response to "[BSE]∎ [PDF] The Great Boer War Illustrated Edition Sir Arthur Conan Doyle 9781406882391 Books"
Post a Comment